PředmětyPředměty(verze: 978)
Předmět, akademický rok 2025/2026
   
Reading Economic Ethnographies (Hidden Valley & Porkopolis) - AETV10005
Anglický název: Reading Economic Ethnographies (Hidden Valley & Porkopolis)
Zajišťuje: Ústav etnologie a středoevropských a balkánských studií (21-UESEBS)
Fakulta: Filozofická fakulta
Platnost: od 2025
Semestr: letní
Body: 0
E-Kredity: 6
Způsob provedení zkoušky: letní s.:
Rozsah, examinace: letní s.:0/2, Zk [HT]
Počet míst: neurčen / 45 (neurčen)
Minimální obsazenost: neomezen
4EU+: ne
Virtuální mobilita / počet míst pro virtuální mobilitu: ne
Kompetence:  
Stav předmětu: vyučován
Jazyk výuky: angličtina
Způsob výuky: prezenční
Úroveň:  
Poznámka: předmět je možno zapsat mimo plán
povolen pro zápis po webu
Garant: André Thiemann, Dr. phil.
Vyučující: André Thiemann, Dr. phil.
Anotace
Reading, writing and discussing books is an essential tool in academia. Therefore, we will take our time and read two monographs together (overly long chapters will be summarized by presentations). The idea is to read a classic and a modern economic/ecological ethnography and to explore both continuities and change in the field. Both books are based on long-term immersion and intimate relationships with their research subjects; they are beautifully written and fun to read. I recommend that you buy your own copies. Affordable paperback versions are available.
First, we read "The Hidden Frontier: Ecology and Ethnicity in an Alpine Valley" (1999 [1974]) by John Cole and the famous Eric Wolf. It addresses core concerns in economic anthropology such as household production, reproduction and inheritance in an Italian- and in a German-speaking community in South Tyrol (Italy). Cole and Wolf also tackle the still burning questions of how the ecology, capitalism and nationalism impact on everyday life.
Second, we will read "Porkopolis: American Animality, Standardized Life, and the Factory Farm" (Blanchette 2020). This stunning (and beautifully illustrated) book is the fruit of empathetic participant observation with pigs, veterinaries and racialized farm and slaughterhouse workers in the USA. Along the “disassembly line,” Alex Blanchette traces how these diverse agents raise, fatten, slaughter and render one of the largest pig herds in the world. Porkopolis revisits themes from Hidden Frontier and newly engages with science and technology, human-animal relations, racism and climate change. 
Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (16.02.2026)
Cíl předmětu

At the end of the course, students will be able to identify classic and contemporary contributions, ideas and concepts in Economic Anthropology. They can use analytic tools in socio-cultural anthropology to pursue independent inquiry into the economy in different world regions and explain different scientific perspectives on the relationships between the economy and society, nature, space and history. They will be able to engage with local and global transformations of the economy in informed and inquisitive ways.

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (09.02.2026)
Deskriptory

Course format

This course combines lectures, student presentations, seminar discussions, and short analyses of different materials. I expect your full, active, and professional participation in class. This means showing up on time (persistently showing up late will negatively affect your participation grade). Respectfully engaging with the course instructor, lecturers, and your peers. Being responsible for the assigned reading and materials: if you miss a class, it is your responsibility to do the reading and get class notes from one of your peers.

Technology

Laptops and tablets are allowed for the purposes of viewing course materials and for taking notes during discussion sections. I strongly prefer that you write your notes by hand. Research shows that writing notes by hand improves your understanding of the material and helps you remember it better, since writing it down involves deeper cognitive processing of the material than typing it. I recognize that not all students can or wish to use handwritten notes. If you do use laptops, do turn off your wi-fi during class time to resist the temptation of email, social media, etc. Cell phones should be silenced and should not be used during class.

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (06.02.2026)
Podmínky zakončení předmětu

The following is a rough overview of how I will evaluate your performance in class. More in-depth descriptions, rubrics, and prompts will be provided with each assignment.

- Class preparation for every week by reading, plus active listening and participation: 30 %

- 2 short presentations of chapters/readings: 50 %

- 1 essay (1 page): 20 %

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (11.02.2026)
Literatura

Cole, John W. and Eric R. Wolf (1999 [1974]). The hidden frontier: ecology and ethnicity in an alpine valley : Internet Archive

Schneider, Jane and Rayna Rapp (1995). Articulating hidden histories: exploring the influence of Eric R. Wolf : Internet Archive

Blanchette, Alex. 2020. Porkopolis: American Animality, Standardized Life, and the Factory Farm. Duke University Press 978-1-4780-0840-8_601.pdf

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (09.02.2026)
Požadavky ke zkoušce

Course readings and syllabus 

I believe that a course and its instructor should be adaptable. This means that readings and course activities may change to suite course developments, forward fruitful discussions, or to address student interests. For this reason, the readings in this syllabus should be regarded as provisional. For any given week, the readings will be available on Moodle. While readings may, from time-to-time change, the course policies and procedures listed in this syllabus will not. It is your responsibility to know them. 

Reading Policy 

All of the course readings for this class can be found on Moodle. In some classes, we will spend significant time discussing particular sections and chapters. In others, we will treat them as background. In all cases, if there is something you don’t understand in the material, it is your responsibility to make sure that you gain an understanding of it by asking questions and raising issues. You are expected to arrive at class ready to discuss the required course readings. 

1 Essay (400 words) 20%

The essays have to be prepared in the following format: Concisely summarise the main arguments of the reading. Analyse the significance of given texts to the structure of the book. Compare and contrast the readings with other texts on the same topic that you are familiar with. Draw parallels from your own experience or from a society that you are familiar with regarding the topic of the presentation. Raise questions related to the topic that can be discussed in class. Share the essays with me one day before class until 23.59 pm.

2 Presentations (8 minutes each) 50%

In your presentation, concisely summarise the main arguments of the reading (e.g. a longish chapter that not everybody needs to read) for the week. Analyse the significance of the given texts to the overall structure of the book. Compare and contrast the readings with other texts on the same topic that you are familiar with. Draw parallels from your own experience or from a society that you are familiar with regarding the topic of the presentation. Raise questions related to the topic that can be discussed in class. 

Policy on Plagiarism

I strongly believe that learning is a collaborative venture. I encourage you to study with your peers, meet to discuss readings with them, and, on assignments, to work together with them. That said, the work that you produce for this course must be your own. There are no exceptions to this rule and no legitimate excuses for violating it. If you fail to acknowledge others’ work or that you are caught overtly plagiarizing from online or written sources, you will receive zero percentage points on the assignment and may be subject to disciplinary procedures.

Office Hours 

Please, feel free to contact me via email for an appointment. 

Attendance

Attendance at the course and section meetings is highly recommended. You are permitted two unexplained course absences per semester. After that, each absence will reduce your overall participation grade by 1/3 of a grade. If you have a legitimate reason to miss class, it is your responsibility to let me know by email before class. 

Statement on Learning Success 

Your success in this class is important to me. We will all need accommodations because we all learn differently. If there are aspects of this course that prevent you from learning or exclude you, please let me know as soon as possible. We will develop strategies to meet both your needs and the requirements of the course. I also encourage you to reach out to the student resources available through Charles University. 

Student Rights & Responsibilities

You have a right to a learning environment that supports mental and physical wellness. You have a right to respect. You have a right to be assessed and graded fairly. You have a right to freedom of opinion and expression. You have a right to privacy and confidentiality. You have a right to meaningful and equal participation, to self-organize groups to improve your learning environment. You have a right to learn in an environment that is welcoming to all people. No student shall be isolated, excluded or diminished in any way. 

With these rights come responsibilities: You are responsible for taking care of yourself, managing your time, and communicating with the teacher, guest lecturers and with others if things start to feel out of control or overwhelming. You are responsible for acting in a way that is worthy of respect and always respectful of others. Your experience with this course is directly related to the quality of the energy that you bring to it, and your energy shapes the quality of your peers’ experiences. You are responsible for creating an inclusive environment and for speaking up when someone is excluded. You are responsible for holding yourself accountable to these standards, holding each other to these standards, and holding the teacher accountable as well. 

Personal Pronoun Preference 

Professional courtesy and sensitivity are especially important with respect to individuals and topics dealing with differences of race, culture, religion, politics, sexual orientation, gender, gender variance, and nationalities. Class rosters are provided to the instructor with the student’s legal name. I will gladly honor your request to address you by a name different than what appears on the roster, and by the gender pronouns you use. Please advise me of this preference early in the semester so that I may make appropriate changes to my records.

Note on academic dishonesty

Plagiarism is a severe crime. In my experience, it mostly comes from students’ insecurity with academic writing that they are relatively new to. Rather than copying someone else’s text and helping AI rephrase it (which makes it much less easily detectable than it was a couple of years ago), I suggest to write your own thoughts in simple words and it will get easier over time.

Note on using AI tools

If you are using AI tools, highlight the part of the text where you have used AI and add a footnote explaining which AI tool and which query you used. You are still required to read, understand, critique and interpret ethnographic texts on your own and form coherent arguments based on your readings. At the same time, I see no issues asking AI tools to help you rephrase your thought. You should still have a go at trying to rephrase the ideas in the text we read in your own words. It can be challenging, especially if you are not a native speaker, but for the next few years, it is still considered a useful skill to have.  Free grammar tools such as Grammarly are recommended for use to improve the legibility of your work.

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (16.02.2026)
Sylabus

Date 

Topic; Description

Readings (1-2) 

16.2. 

Introduction: On Reading monographs in Economic Anthropology

23.2.

Cole, John W. and Eric R. Wolf (1999 [1974]). The hidden frontier: ecology and ethnicity in an alpine valley / with a new introduction incl. Chapter I (everybody: xv–xx; 1–24)

Contents; PREFACE; ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

INTRODUCTION (xv-xx)

Chapter I. The Inquiry Two Villages: Fieldwork; The Politics of Place Names; Questions and Answers (1–24)

2.3.

Chapters II, III, IV (everybody: 64–95)

(Presentation) Chapter II. The Forging of Tyrolese Identity: The Alpine Landscape; Prehistory; New Settlers; Political Consolidation; Trade and Mining; The Peasant Revolt; The Counter-Reformation; Economic and Political Decline (25–49)

(Presentation) Chapter III. Torments of Nationalism: Italian Unification; German Unification; Nationalist Rivalry; World War I; Fascism; The Plebiscite (50–63)

Chapter IV. The Economic Development of the Rural Sector: Early Middle Ages: Sixth-Eleventh Centuries 67 Late Middle Ages: Twelfth—Sixteenth Centuries 70 The Early Modern Period: Sixteenth-Seventeenth Centuries Fah Tyrol and Trentino Contrasted 79 The Economic Margin of the State 81 Changing Economic Relations 83 The Fascist Interlude 88 The Postwar Boom 92 (6495)

9.3. 

Chapters V, VI (everybody: 119–152)

(Presentation) Chapter V. History of an Upland Valley 96 The Roman Frontier 96 Bishop and Count 97 Communes 99 German Settlement 100 Peasant Revolts 108 The Impact of the Counter-Reformation 109 The French Invasion 112 Population: St. Felix and Tret 113 The Impact of Nationalism 115 (96–118)

Chapter VI. Mountain Husbandry 119 The Ecology of Mountain Agriculture 125 The Annual Cycle 127 The Organization of Village Resources 136 The Limits of Expansion 145 The Facts of Life 151 (119–52)

16.3. 

Chapters VII-VIII, Appendices 1-4 (everybody: 175–204)

(Presentation) Chapter VII. The Mountain Estate 153 Rights in Estates 154 Economic Pursuits 160 The Organization of Labor 168 (153–74)

Chapter VIII. Inheritance 175 The Ideology of Inheritance 176 The Realities of Life 180 Ecological Constraints 181 The Age Factor in Inheritance 182 The Inheritance Process in Tret 187 The Inheritance Process in St. Felix 195 Inheritance and Women 198 Secondary Heirs 200 Summary 202 (175–204)

(Presentation) Appendix 1. Population Statistics 289; Appendix 2. Interview Sheet 292; Appendix 3. Representative Holdings in Tret and St. Felix Case 1: The ‘Mill Estate’ In Tret Case 2: Three Brothers’ Estates in Tret Case 3: The Forest Warden in Tret Case 4: The ‘Big Estate” in St. Felix Case 5: The Estate in the Woods Case 6: Four Estates in St. Felix (293–314); Appendix 4. Interethnic Marriages St. Felix: 560 Marriages on Record Tret: 366 Marriages on Record (289–318)

23.3. 

Chapters IX-XI (everybody: 206–32)

Chapter IX. The New Economic Order Changing Circumstances The Response in Tret The Response in St. Felix Tret and St. Felix Compared The Material Basis of the Good Life Prosperity and Misfortune (206–32)

(Presentation) Chapter X. Kith and Kin Domestic Groups Authority Marriage Associations (233–62)

(Presentation) Chapter XI. Cultural Confrontation (263–88)

30.3. 

Spring Reading Week 

no class

6.4. 

Porkopolis: American animality, standardized life, and the factory farm / by Alex Blanchette (i–30)

CONTENTS i

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS vii

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ix

PREFACE WATCHING HOGS WATCH WORKERS xiii

A NOTE ON PHOTOGRAPHY xvii

INTRODUCTION THE “FACTORY” FARM 1–30

13.4. 

Part I. Boar (31–70)

ONE THE DOVER FLIES 33

(Presentation) TWO THE HERD: INTIMATE BIOSECURITY AND POSTHUMAN LABOR 45

20.4. 

Part II. Sow (71–117)

THREE SOMOS PUERCOS 73

(Presentation) FOUR STIMULATION: INSTINCTS IN PRODUCTION 89

27.4. 

No class (workshop attendance by the lecturer)

3.5. 

 PART III. HOG (119–63)

FIVE LUTALYSE 121

(Presentation) SIX STOCKPERSON: LOVE, MUSCLES, AND THE INDUSTRIAL RUNT 137–63

10.5.

Part IV. Carcass (165200)

SEVEN MISS WICKED 167

(Presentation) EIGHT BIOLOGICAL SYSTEM: BREAKING IN AT THE END OF INDUSTRIAL TIME 177

17.5.

Part V. Viscera (201–46)

NINE MAYBE SOME BLOOD, BUT MOSTLY GREASE 201–

(Presentation) TEN LIFECYCLE: ON USING ALL OF THE PORCINE SPECIES 211–37

EPILOGUE THE (DE-)INDUSTRIALIZATION OF THE WORLD 239–46

1.6. ff. 

Written and Oral Exams

 

Poslední úprava: Thiemann André, Dr. phil. (09.02.2026)
 
Univerzita Karlova | Informační systém UK